I ordered one each for my Chi, my Yorkie, and my cat. The quality is good. No sharp edges, and the etching is nice and deep. Also, the engraving is on both sides, which I didn't realize until receipt, but it's a nice touch! I ordered the star shape; it is a bit large on these little guys, but that's just me underestimating what 1.5in would look like. That said, it still looks cute. I've ordered from cnet tags previously, and am always happy with the product and shipping times.