Sadly, this was too heavy for my cat because it's super cute and well made. If you're ordering this for a dog, I say go for it. A small kitty though, may think she is being punished. Seriously, this thing freaked her out. I'm positive it was the weight. It really does have crystals on it - not just an engraved star thing like many others. It's a great looking tag. I think I'll hang it on the Christmas tree this year LOL. I was disappointed in the amount of time it took to arrive, although to their credit, the seller did send an email. My cats behavior was not reason to remove a star but I'd give 4.5 if it were possible, due to the shipping time.