I just received my military style dog tag, promptly and as described. It looks well constructed and will do the job. I withheld the 5th star not because of the tag itself, but the small ring provided to attach the tag to the collar. Maybe it's just me, but I found the attaching ring provided to be on the small side, thin and the smooth ring surface I suspected could lead to wear or loss. I transferred the tag to a larger, thicker ring that had an alternating (larger, then smaller, then larger diameter) surface.